SentientEdge

Research letters · 13 November 2026

Research letter, 13 November 2026

This week

The most careful papers this week mostly find nothing. In one, a live deflated-Sharpe gate inside an LLM strategy search refused to certify 36 of 37 runs. In another, a quantum layer in a stock ranker turned out to add nothing: a frozen random version matched the trained one, and removing it entirely did no harm. The one positive result comes from a paper built so it could fail. A pre-registered retest found the end-of-day reversal in S&P 500 stocks still present after 2019, but every proposed mechanism test failed.

This is a short letter: four items, all from arXiv. We found no new SSRN or NBER papers in these areas from the past two weeks that we could verify. One journal paper we have not yet read in full is listed under Watching.

1. Can a search hold its own bar? In-loop deflation and its exploits in autonomous strategy discovery

Eray Gençay · submitted 14 Oct 2026, announced in the November listings · arXiv:2611.14539 · code, configs and full run traces at Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.21725589. The full platform is available on request.

Method.

What they tested and found.

Limitations.

Evidence vs speculation.

What we will do with it. We run several shadow variants in parallel and judge each on its own, which is exactly the setting this paper warns about. We will treat the whole set as one search, estimate its effective number of distinct trials, and compute the paper's bar on that count. If our live momentum variant's Sharpe since going live sits below that bar, we stop citing its live record as evidence of edge until a full year of live weeks has settled.

2. Trained, Frozen, or Absent: Identifying What a Quantum Layer Contributes to Cross-Sectional Equity Ranking

Chi-Sheng Chen, Xinyu Zhang, En-Jui Kuo, Rong Fu, Qiuzhe Xie, Fan Zhang · 7 Nov 2026 · arXiv:2611.10801 · code, per-cell results and weights at github.com/ChiShengChen/qtcnn-trained-frozen-absent. The JPX data is public but not redistributed.

Ignore the quantum part. This is a useful paper because it is a self-audit, and the design transfers to any added component.

Method.

What they tested and found.

Limitations.

Evidence vs speculation.

What we will do with it. Our composite shadow score adds a regime term that takes the same value for every stock on a given date, so it cannot reorder stocks against each other. We will recompute the composite with the regime term held constant and with regime labels shuffled in blocks, and compare the resulting top-25 books with the live ones. If the books are unchanged, the regime term is recorded as inert in the composite and no composite result may be attributed to regime again; regime conditioning would then need its own exposure-level test.

3. The End-of-Day Reversal After 2019: A Pre-Registered Test on S&P 500 Stocks Excluding Heavily Traded Names

Alex Vidovich, Zivana Zerjal · 6 Nov 2026 · arXiv:2611.09286 · replication archive with code, point-in-time membership, the leveraged-ETF launch table and the pre-registration documents with SHA-256 hashes at Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.24003093. The details below come from the abstract and the archive's pre-registration file rather than the full text.

Method.

What they tested and found (bps per day; positive = reversal).

Limitations.

Evidence vs speculation.

What we will do with it. We don't trade the last half hour, so the finding itself isn't useful to us. The protocol is: a gate on old data before newer data may be opened, a run-once hearing, a power table, and especially the shuffled-outcome false-PASS check. Our own promotion scorecard has never had its false-pass rate measured. We will rebuild our weekly books on shuffled forward returns 200 times and run the unchanged scorecard on each. If it passes noise more than one time in ten, every promotion read is suspended until the thresholds are re-derived from that null; if not, the rate goes into the scorecard header and we continue.

4. Idiosyncratic Market Effects in Global Time Series Momentum

Andrew Butler, Maciej Zawadzki, Adam Butler (ReSolve) · 11 Nov 2026 · arXiv:2611.15646 · no code. The futures data comes from a commercial vendor (CSI).

Method.

What they tested and found.

Limitations.

Evidence vs speculation.

What we will do with it. Our clean momentum variant selects on raw 12-1 return, so it probably loads on exactly the extreme readings this paper says do poorly. We will split historical picks by volatility-scaled momentum and compare the extreme group's forward excess return with the rest, across 2008 to 2026 and in both halves of that period. Unless extremes underperform clearly in both, the idea is dropped for good and no vol-capped variant gets built. A pass only earns a shadow variant, not a change.

Promising experiments

  1. The regime "absent" ablation (item 2). It is the cheapest test here, an afternoon of recompute. The answer is nearly decidable from the arithmetic: a constant added to every stock can't reorder stocks. Running it pins down what the composite shadow's regime channel actually does, and stops us crediting regime for results it can't have caused.
  2. The scorecard's false-PASS rate under shuffled outcomes (item 3). We have never measured how often our own promotion machinery passes noise. Last week's PROMOTE paper says repeated looks almost always promote something. This test measures it on our own scorecard rather than assuming.
  3. The in-loop bar on our own variant ledger (item 1). It is mostly bookkeeping, but it would give the first honest count of how many distinct hypotheses we have actually tested.

Watching / not yet credible

Updates

Nothing previously covered appeared as a revised version in this week's listings. Older items were not systematically re-checked for new versions.

Item 1 adds to last week's thread on gating adaptive searches (PROMOTE, 2611.03384; LLM agents as judges of predictability, 2611.04070) and to "Deflate by Bits, Not Trials" (SSRN-7557458, covered earlier). Taken together: deflating by trial count fails under adaptive search, whether it's applied once at the end or checked live inside the loop. And none of these papers has shown a gate that passes a planted, realistic edge.


This letter is drafted with AI research assistance and reviewed and signed by Bob Katz. It is research commentary, not investment advice. No result described here is a claim net of trading costs unless stated, and the experiments listed are planned tests of our own models, not findings.